Season 4 Episode 43: The Mistakes I Learned After Trying Every Diet

In this deeply personal episode, I share my full story — not just how I entered the health and fitness world…but how I discovered the missing piece that changed everything.

This is a conversation about identity, pain, food obsession, and the moment I realized: “I know exactly what to do… so why can’t I do it?”

The Injury That Changed Everything

I take you back to being a teenage athlete — strong, competitive, and deeply connected to my body — until a life-altering moment shifted everything.

At just 16 years old, I was in a severe accident that led to emergency back surgery and one devastating message:

“You’ll never play sports again.”

What followed were years of:

  • Disconnection from my body
  • Reliance on pain medication
  • Living in constant awareness of pain
  • Losing the identity I once knew

My world became smaller.
My body became something to manage… instead of something to trust.

The Wake-Up Call

In my early 20s, after a night that left me feeling completely disconnected, I had a moment of truth:

“Who have I become?”

That question became my turning point.

Instead of accepting the story I had been given, I made one simple decision:
I signed up for a gym.

No plan.
No knowledge.
No certainty.

Just a willingness to begin.

Rebuilding Through Repetition

What followed wasn’t perfection — it was consistency.

  • Copying workouts
  • Showing up week after week
  • Learning through doing
  • Reconnecting with my body slowly

And then something incredible happened:

My pain started to disappear.
I got off medication.
I began running — first 5 minutes… then an hour.

A moment that once felt impossible became reality.

And in that moment, a new purpose was born:

“If I can do this… I need to help others do this too.”

The Search for the “Right Way” to Eat

As I built my career — studying exercise science, becoming an athletic therapist and osteopath, opening gyms — I became obsessed with one question:

What is the right way to eat?

What followed was a journey through nearly every diet:

  • Calorie counting
  • Low-fat
  • Atkins
  • Paleo
  • Keto
  • Zone
  • Plant-based

Each backed by science.
Each promising results.
Each adding another layer of confusion.

When Knowledge Turns Into Fear

What started as education slowly became obsession.

Food became:

  • Something to control
  • Something to label as “good” or “bad”
  • Something tied to my identity and worth

And behind the scenes, something deeper was happening:

Fear.

Despite being the “expert”…
Despite coaching others…
Despite knowing everything about nutrition…

My relationship with food was unraveling.

From Discipline to Bingeing

What began as a controlled “cheat meal” evolved into something far more intense:

  • Weekend-long binge cycles
  • Eating in secret
  • Hiding from clients
  • Feeling completely out of control

And then came the realization that changed everything:

“I can’t stop.”

Not because I didn’t know what to do —
but because something deeper was driving the behavior.

The Missing Piece: The Nervous System

This is where everything shifted.

I realized:
If someone like me — with this much knowledge, discipline, and experience — is struggling…

This isn’t about food.

It’s about the nervous system.
It’s about safety.
It’s about patterns happening beneath awareness.

I also saw the same pattern in the people I was working with:

They could follow a plan.
They could get results.
But the moment the structure disappeared…

They went right back to old habits.

The Truth This Episode Reveals

You don’t struggle because you lack knowledge.

You struggle because:

  • Your nervous system is seeking safety
  • Your identity hasn’t shifted yet
  • Your patterns are stronger than your plans

Download my free guide, Calm the Craving: 7 Steps to Break Emotional and Binge Eating, and finally end the cycle of out-of-control eating: www.sherryshaban.com

Work With Sherry Shaban:
Book your FREE 30-minute Food Freedom Call and start your journey to lasting change! www.sherryshabanfitness.com/clarity

Listen & Subscribe
Catch more episodes at www.makepeacewithfood.com/podcast or subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube so you never miss an episode!

Connect & Go Deeper

Share Your Takeaway
Tag us on Instagram (@makepeacewithfoodofficial), Facebook (@MakePeaceWithFoodOfficial), TikTok (@sherryshaban), or LinkedIn (sherryshaban) and share your biggest insight from this episode!

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *